The following are two answers by ai (notebookLM.google.com), based on 35 resources written by Joel S. Goldsmith:
Can we have a personal relationship with God?
NotebookLM.Google.com:
According to the sources , you can have a relationship with God that is intimate and personal, but it is not a relationship between two separate beings. True spiritual relationship is based on the realization of oneness, where the sense of a selfhood apart from God is overcome.
From Duality to Oneness
The sources emphasize that the traditional concept of a “personal relationship”—where a human being on earth reaches out to a God in heaven—is a form of duality or “twoness” that actually creates a sense of separation.
- The Error of Separation: Believing that you are “wo/man” and that somewhere else there is “God” is described as a “pagan” concept that was later incorporated into Christianity.
- The Reality of Oneness: The core relationship revealed by mystics is: “I and my Father are one”. This means God is not an entity external to you, but is the very substance, life, and consciousness of your individual being.
An Intimate, Inner Experience
While God is universal and impersonal in nature, the experience of God becomes deeply personal when realized within one’s own consciousness.
- Intimate Titles: The sources note that throughout scripture, individuals have known God in personal ways: Abraham knew God as “Friend,” while Jesus revealed God as “Father”. Others have experienced God as “Mother” or “Father-Mother”.
- Closer than Breathing: This relationship is described as being “nearer than hands and feet” and “closer than breathing”.
- The Inner Sanctuary: You do not find this relationship in holy temples or through rituals, but in the “inner sanctuary” of your own consciousness. It is an “inner communion” or “tabernacling” with the Spirit within.
The Role of the Indwelling Christ
The “personal” aspect of the relationship is often experienced as a connection between the individual’s outer human self and the indwelling Christ (the Son of God within).
- The Mediator: This divine Center within acts as a “Mediator” or “connecting link” between the individual and the absolute Source.
- Divine Partnership: This is described as a “divine partnership” where you are no longer fighting battles alone, but realize that “I and my Father” are together.
- Spiritual Companionship: By finding this inner relationship with God, you also find a “spiritual bond” with all people, which enhances human companionships and removes barriers of race or religion.
The Ultimate Goal: Conscious Union
The goal of the spiritual life is to move from “talking about God” to a God-experience.
- Listening, Not Telling: True relationship involves a “listening ear” and a “silent communion” rather than attempting to influence God or tell Him what you need.
- Disappearance of the “I”: In the highest state of this relationship, called conscious union, the separate, personal selfhood disappears, and only God is felt to be present.
- Self-Completeness: In this union, you discover you are “Self-complete in God,” meaning you no longer look to any human being or external circumstance for your fulfillment, health, or supply.
Is the relationship to God personal?
NotebookLM.Google.com:
According to the sources, the relationship to God is both universal and impersonal in its nature, yet deeply intimate and personal in its individual realization.
God as Universal and Impersonal
God is understood as universal Being whose laws function without exceptions or favoritism. In this sense, the relationship is not personal because:
- God has no favorites: God is no respecter of persons, religions, races, or nationalities.
- Impartial Activity: God’s activity is not directed at one individual over another; His grace falls on the saint and the sinner alike.
- No Personal Influence: Human beings cannot influence, sway, or persuade God through rituals or pleading to do something special for them.
- Universal Provision: God does not “set a table” for one person specifically but provides for the entire universe.
God as Individual and Intimate
While God is universal, the sources emphasize that God is incarnated as individual consciousness. This makes the relationship profoundly personal to the individual:
- The Father Within: Jesus referred to this relationship as the “Father within,” indicating an intimate, indwelling presence.
- Intimacy of Experience: Once God is felt and experienced, He ceases to be an abstract principle and becomes a “gentle friend,” “divine love,” or “Father”.
- Closer Than Breathing: God is described as being closer than one’s own breathing and nearer than hands or feet.
- The True Identity of “I”: The ultimate intimate revelation is that the “I” of your being is God. In this realization, you are not separate from God; God constitutes your very mind, soul, and life.
The Relationship of Oneness
The core relationship taught in the sources is oneness—a state of divine sonship that is indivisible and indestructible.
- Individual Union: Although God is universal, each person must find their own center in God individually; one cannot enter “heaven” two by two.
- Tabernacling: Spiritual living involves “tabernacling” or communing with God at the center of one’s own being in sacredness and secrecy.
- Self-Sufficiency: In this relationship, an individual finds their sufficiency within their own “Self” (God), rather than looking to other people or external circumstances.
In summary, while God is an impersonal, universal Principle that does not grant personal favors, the experience of God is the most personal and intimate relationship an individual can have, as it is the discovery of God as one’s own spiritual identity and life.


Leave a Reply to God does not exist. – me-voice.comCancel reply